Second Storey Addition vs Extending Out: Which Is Right for Your House?
A direct comparison of building up and building out, with a simple way to decide based on your block, structure, budget and council rules.
Second storey addition vs extending out: the quick answer
Build up if your block is small, you want to keep your garden and your existing structure can carry another level. Build out if you have the space, the structure is not suited to a new storey, or you want a simpler build.
Neither is always cheaper. The answer comes from your block, your house and your council rules.
Quick answer
Start with three checks: how much land is free, whether the existing footings and walls can take a new level, and what height and setback limits apply. Those three usually decide it.
Building up and building out compared
| Second storey addition | Extending out | |
|---|---|---|
| Keeps your garden | Yes | No, it uses yard space |
| New foundations | Usually not for the new level, but the existing ones may need work | Yes |
| Structural work | Higher, because the house must carry a new level | Lower for most homes |
| Roof | Usually removed and rebuilt | Usually tied into the existing roof |
| Stairs | Needed | Not needed |
| Disruption | Higher, especially while the roof is off | Lower inside the existing house |
| Council focus | Height, overshadowing and privacy | Setbacks, floor area and landscaped area |
| Best for | Small blocks and homes with sound structure | Larger blocks and simpler builds |
Our guides to second storey addition costs and house extension costs explain what drives the price of each.
Building up: the pros and cons
Pros
- Keeps your outdoor space
- Adds a lot of living area on a small block
- Can bring views and privacy from the upper level
- You may be able to stay in part of the house during some stages
- Avoids the cost of moving
Cons
- The existing structure may need strengthening
- Height limits and neighbour impacts can restrict the design
- The roof comes off, so weather protection is needed
- Stairs take space on both levels
- The build can be longer and more disruptive
Building out: the pros and cons
Pros
- Often simpler structurally
- Easier to connect to the living areas
- Good for accessibility and step free living
- Usually less disruption to the existing rooms
- More flexible layout
Cons
- Uses garden and outdoor space
- Needs new foundations and drainage work
- Setbacks and landscaped area rules can limit the size
- May reduce natural light into the existing rooms
- Larger footprint can cost more on a large extension
How to decide which suits your house
- Measure how much land is free, after setbacks and landscaped area
- Ask an engineer whether the existing footings and walls can carry another level
- Check council height, setback and overshadowing rules
- Think about whether you want to keep the garden
- Decide how much disruption you can accept
- Ask a drafter to sketch both options before you commit
What approval does each option need?
Both options normally need a complying development certificate or a development application, plus a BASIX certificate. The details differ. Upper levels draw more attention to height and shadows. Ground floor additions draw more attention to setbacks and landscaped area.
Read our guide on whether you need a DA for a house extension.
House Plan Design & Drafting's Sutherland Shire page explains how the local council treats additions.
Mistakes to avoid
- Choosing before checking the structure
- Assuming building up is always cheaper
- Ignoring height limits and overshadowing
- Forgetting stairs in the floor plan
- Not budgeting for temporary accommodation
- Hiring a builder before the plans are approved
Your next step
Not sure whether to go up or out? Tell us about your house and block. We will check the planning rules and sketch what each option could look like.
Building up or out questions Sydney homeowners ask
Is it cheaper to build up or out?
Neither is always cheaper. Building up needs structural work and stairs. Building out needs new foundations and uses more land. Compare written quotes for both.
Can my house take a second storey?
It depends on the existing footings, walls and roof. A structural engineer can assess this before you commit to a design.
Will a second storey block my neighbour's light?
It can. Councils look at overshadowing and privacy, and your drawings may need shadow diagrams.
Do I need to move out during a second storey addition?
Often for at least part of the build, because the roof comes off. Plan for this in your budget.
Does extending out reduce my garden too much?
It can. Setbacks and landscaped area rules also limit how much of the block you can build on.
Which one adds more value?
It depends on your area and the quality of the work. A local agent can advise on what buyers want in your street.
Deciding between building up and out in Sydney?
Tell us about your project. We will explain which drawings and approvals it needs and give you a fixed fee quote before any work begins.